Make a Buttery, Moist, Perfect Pound Cake by Avoiding These Common Mistakes (2024)

If you've ever had a piece of subpar pound cake, you know how depressing it can be. What should be sweet and soft is nothing more than a heavy, dry piece of bread masquerading as cake. But a good piece of pound cake? That's a whole different ball game. "Pound cake should be light, with a finely textured, moist, and even crumb," says Claire Saffitz, BA's associate food editor and baker extraordinaire. She has created, tested, and made dozens of pound cakes, plus she's well-versed in the science of baking (yep, it's a science). We caught up with Saffitz in the test kitchen to outline the eight steps necessary for pound cake perfection. Are you making any of these common mistakes?

1. Don't Just Scoop Your Dry Ingredients

"Whisk your dry ingredients to remove lumps," says Saffitz, "Then use the fluff, spoon, and level method." The what? To execute this technique, use a fork or whisk to fluff up the flour, then spoon it into the measuring cup. Finally, level it with a knife. This method is superior to the scoop method, because simply dunking and filling the measuring cup can result in too-densely packed flour.

2. Let Your Eggs and Butter Come to Room Temperature. If They're Not…Wait!

Not only should your eggs and butter be at room temperature, but they should also all be the same temperature. Adding cold eggs to warm butter will cause them to seize. Set the eggs and butter out on the counter for several hours before you plan to bake. Also, never cheat by softening butter in the microwave. It will get too hot—and partially melted butter doesn't perform properly in the creaming stage.

3. Take the Time to Thoroughly Cream Your Batter

This is the most important tip to remember for perfect pound cake. How do you know if your ingredients are "thoroughly" creamed? Expect to use your stand or electric mixer for at least five minutes—or more. Don't stop when the mixture looks combined. "It should be very pale in color; almost white," Saffitz explains. And yes, you really do need to use butter for pound cake. The sharp edges of the sugar granules slice through butter, creating air pockets that expand further when baked. Only butter captures and holds these pockets, so there really is no substitute. (Well, except for coconut oil, which performs similarly. This recipe uses a combination of both.)

4. …But Don't Overmix

Once your butter and sugar are creamed, add the dry ingredients in stages. Saffitz recommends stopping the electric mixer when you begin to see white streaks running through the batter. Use a wide spatula to gently fold in the rest of the flour. "Gently" is key here; overmixing with a heavy hand will cause the batter to deflate, and all your hard work creaming will be reversed. The result will be a dense, tough cake.

Make a Buttery, Moist, Perfect Pound Cake by Avoiding These Common Mistakes (2024)

FAQs

What are common mistakes when baking a cake? ›

Common Baking Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
  • Baking at the wrong temperature. ...
  • Not measuring ingredients. ...
  • Checking on your items too frequently. ...
  • Your ingredients are at the wrong temperature. ...
  • Your dough isn't rising. ...
  • Nothing is baking evenly. ...
  • Your dough or batter is too tough. ...
  • Wrap Up.

Does oil or butter make a cake more moist? ›

Replacing the water from the butter with oil means there's more fat left in the cakes to ensure tenderness. It also coats the flour uniformly, which keeps the layers from being tough even if the batter is overbeaten.

Should you sift flour when making a pound cake? ›

Make sure the flour is sifted before you add it to the cake. It's even better if you can sift it AGAIN when you're adding it to the cake, but that's not necessary. This is to reduce the likelihood of flour lumps forming when mixing the flour. If you're able to incorporate the flour with a baking spatula – DO IT!

What are the three common causes of failure in cakes? ›

1) You forgot to add baking powder, or you used expired baking powder. 2) Your pan is too big, so the mixture can't rise enough to fill it. Or 3) You over whisked.

What happens if you put too much butter in cake batter? ›

Too Much or Too Soft of Butter

If the butter yields too easily to pressure and appears melted and oily, it will produce a silky batter that rises too soon and collapses. Your cake will have big air pockets and an uneven texture.

What to add to a cake mix to make it more moist? ›

Add an Extra Egg

Most cake mixes call for two to three eggs. Just one more egg will add extra moisture, fat, and a little protein, which means the cake will be softer and less likely to overbake and dry out in the oven.

What liquid keeps cakes moist? ›

The simplest version of simple syrup, or soak, is nothing more than equal parts granulated sugar dissolved into water. The basic soak alone will do great things for your cake, especially in terms of moisture.

Is it better to put sour cream or milk in a cake? ›

It produces tender, moist cakes every time. Kelly is a former associate digital food editor for MarthaStewart.com. Have you ever tasted a slice of vanilla pound cake or rich, creamy cheesecake and wondered what makes it so tender, airy, and moist? The answer is sour cream.

Is it better to bake pound cake at 325 or 350? ›

Preheat oven to 325°F (163°C). Not 350°F. Generously grease a 10-12 cup Bundt pan with butter or nonstick spray. Using a handheld or stand mixer fitted with a paddle or whisk attachment, beat the butter on high speed until smooth and creamy, about 2 minutes.

Why is my pound cake not moist? ›

A dry cake is usually the result of one of the following pitfalls: using the wrong ingredients, making mistakes while measuring or mixing the batter, or baking the cake too long or at too high a temperature.

Should pound cake batter be thick? ›

Unlike layer cakes, which use a thin batter that should never fill the pan more than halfway (more on that here), pound cake batter is thick, and should fill the pan within an inch of the top to encourage a prominent crown.

How many eggs equal one pound? ›

How many eggs are in a pound? Eggs vary in weight since not all eggs are the same. Large eggs tend to weigh just short of 2 ounces each. It takes between 8 and 9 large eggs to equal one pound.

What causes a pound cake to be heavy? ›

Store brands of sugar are often more finely ground than name brands, yielding more sugar per cup, which can cause the cake to fall. Store brands of butter may contain more liquid fat, and flours more hard wheat, making the cake heavy.

Why does my pound cake collapse in the middle? ›

Overbeating, Overmixing, or Undermixing Your Cake Batter

Too much air and your cake will collapse because it simply can't hold onto all that air. Overbeating can add too much additional air and/or large air bubbles which the cake can't support, causing it to collapse in the oven.

What are five faults in cake making? ›

Common Cake Baking Mistakes
  • Too Dense. If you've ever baked a dense cake that never seems to rise properly, there are a few reasons why this can happen. ...
  • Cake Overflows. ...
  • A Sunken Cake. ...
  • Stuck to the Pan. ...
  • Crusty Edges. ...
  • Cake Batter is Too Stiff. ...
  • Fruit Falling to the Bottom. ...
  • Cake Sides Caving In.
May 23, 2022

What not to do while baking? ›

Things you should not do while baking:
  1. Not Reading the Recipe Carefully: ...
  2. Mixing Too Much: ...
  3. Using Cold Ingredients: ...
  4. Skipping Sifting: ...
  5. Forgetting to Preheat the Oven: ...
  6. Opening the Oven Door Too Much: ...
  7. Ignoring the Timer: ...
  8. Not Measuring Ingredients Properly:
Oct 18, 2023

What is the most important rule in baking? ›

#1 Read through the recipe

Make sure to quickly skim the recipe before you start baking to understand the general flow and key steps. You can even make notes on the recipe or highlight key points to help you along.

What causes a cake to fall in the middle after baking? ›

This is because too much batter in one cake tin may result in the weight of the batter being too much for the cake to support, causing the cake to collapse and sink in the middle as it bakes.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tish Haag

Last Updated:

Views: 6389

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tish Haag

Birthday: 1999-11-18

Address: 30256 Tara Expressway, Kutchburgh, VT 92892-0078

Phone: +4215847628708

Job: Internal Consulting Engineer

Hobby: Roller skating, Roller skating, Kayaking, Flying, Graffiti, Ghost hunting, scrapbook

Introduction: My name is Tish Haag, I am a excited, delightful, curious, beautiful, agreeable, enchanting, fancy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.